![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
HHGttG
The movie struck me as more a homage than a stand-alone offering. There were references that were half-there, which is enough if you've read the books (or seen the TV show or heard the radio show) and meaningless otherwise. I wonder if those bits of time could have been better spent, in one direction or the other.
The original story (in any of its myriad forms) is more episodic than the movie, in that individual sections stood alone and not everything had to obviously fit into the Big Story by the end of the half-hour. The movie tried to make over-riding themes obvious and, well, over-riding, perhaps because they only had two hours. But in some cases they missed the mark IMO; the recurring bad guys in the movie struck me as a distraction rather than an enhancement, though there were some cute bits there.
There were lots of cute bits; I definitely laughed out loud in places. ("Zest." Hee hee.) The density of fun/clever bits wasn't as high as I had hoped (or remember from other flavors); it felt like there was a lot more padding in the movie.
(On the one hand I shouldn't judge the movie in comparison to the other forms; I should judge it on its own. But on the other hand, the makers of the movie know that most of their viewers will have that background, so it's not entirely unfair to take it into account.)
I do not particularly mind the assorted minor plot changes, because every retelling of the story has involved some of that. And Douglas Adams wrote the script, so one can hardly argue that people are butchering his vision of the story.
I talked to my father recently; he saw the movie and had not had previous HHGttG exposure. His reaction was pretty much "eh". I told him that the other forms were very good and I was looking forward to the movie, but now that I've seen it, I have to agree with his assessment. Eh. Not bad, not great; I'm not longing for my two hours back, but perhaps I should have caught a matinee. And I should lend my father either my radio tapes or my tape of the TV show.
Trailers:
- Zathura: During the trailer I was thinking of Home Alone with a fantasy twist; at the end they said it's from the people who did Polar Express. I'm guessing that this means it's really for kids and that there won't be a second layer for adults, but I'd be happy to hear that I'm wrong.
- Valiant: Carrier pigeons dodge evil falcons to save humanity. Looks like fun animation and maybe not much story. Can't really tell.
- Shark Boy and Lava Girl: If it's a riff on comic books then it could be fun, but from the trailer I infer that it's more of a "heartwarming" children's story that just uses comic-book heroes as a plot device. What exactly do they think HHGttG's demographic is?
- Pink Panther: Looks like a respectable version. I didn't care for the originals myself, but that's just me. One of these trailers is not like the others. :-)
- Herbie: Ok, this looks like fun! Now that's closer to pegging the demographic!
Hmm, why are they called "trailers" when they come before the movie?
no subject
'cause they figured out that no one stayed for them when they used to put them after the movie...?
no subject
no subject
Well, at least that part hasn't changed. :P
no subject
no subject
no subject
Why are you boycotting WotW? (I'm not judgemental, just curious.)
no subject
From what I saw from the trailer, they took a random alien invasion/disaster movie with massive special effects and slapped the title on it for name recognition. I don't really have a problem with folks going so perhaps boycott was too strong a word, but I have no interest in yet another random movie of this sort. I liked it the first time (Independence Day) but it's getting old now.
no subject
Oh yuck. I was kind of expecting, y'know, something resembling Wells' story. Having now downloaded the trailers, I agree with your assessment. I'll wait to see what others say before I decide whether to go.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
I am told that once upon a time, each movie had its *own* preview(s) immediately afterwards on the last reel. Not sure why they would do this, or if my info is even accurate, but it *would* explain the term.
no subject
Batman Begins(ooo, cool.)
Ep III: (could be cool.)
Somewhere in there was also Chicken Little and Zathura and Herbie, but in the middle there was a super-creepy promo for Dark Water, which interrupted and spoiled the whole "ooh, cool geeky fun stuff" mood.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject