Entry tags:
Jewish minutiae
A few days ago
goljerp raised the question of why we don't say the Rosh Chodesh (new month) prayers on Rosh Hashana. Rosh Hashana is, after all, a new month as well as the beginning of the new year.
I asked Rabbi Berkun this morning, and his answer is that Rosh Hashana, being a much bigger deal, replaces Rosh Chodesh. (He says, by the way, that we do not do the Rosh Chodesh additions to bentching, the prayer after a meal, so there's no inconsistency between liturgy and home observance after all.) Someone else had an interesting comment: Rosh Hashana commemorates the creation of the world; therefore, there was no time before RH and RH isn't a "new" month but the first month. So the first Rosh Chodesh would be the beginning of the following month. I find this explanation somewhat elegant.
For those who might be wondering why we keep the Shabbat prayers in the service on a holiday when the preceeding would seem to suggest that this should be omitted, it's because Shabbat is more important than holidays. Yes, really. The only Shabbat concession we make for a holiday is that if Yom Kippur falls on Shabbat we do in fact fast on that day. Yom Kippur is described in Torah as the "Shabbat of Shabbats", though, so it's special.
I asked Rabbi Berkun this morning, and his answer is that Rosh Hashana, being a much bigger deal, replaces Rosh Chodesh. (He says, by the way, that we do not do the Rosh Chodesh additions to bentching, the prayer after a meal, so there's no inconsistency between liturgy and home observance after all.) Someone else had an interesting comment: Rosh Hashana commemorates the creation of the world; therefore, there was no time before RH and RH isn't a "new" month but the first month. So the first Rosh Chodesh would be the beginning of the following month. I find this explanation somewhat elegant.
For those who might be wondering why we keep the Shabbat prayers in the service on a holiday when the preceeding would seem to suggest that this should be omitted, it's because Shabbat is more important than holidays. Yes, really. The only Shabbat concession we make for a holiday is that if Yom Kippur falls on Shabbat we do in fact fast on that day. Yom Kippur is described in Torah as the "Shabbat of Shabbats", though, so it's special.